Estragole is an aromatic compound widely found in various aromatic plants and used for its olfactory and gustatory properties. While valued in several sectors, including perfumery and food , this compound raises concerns about its health impact and potential toxicity at certain doses.
This article offers an in-depth exploration of estragole, its chemical characteristics and its natural occurrence, addressing the laboratory analyses that allow it to be detected and precisely measured.
What is estragole?
Definition and main characteristics
Estragol, also known as p-allylanisole or methylchavicol, is an organic compound belonging to the phenylpropene family, a subcategory of phenylpropanoids. Its chemical formula is C10H12O, and its structure consists of a benzene ring with two substituent groups: a methoxy group (-OCH3) and an allyl group (-CH2CH=CH2), both in the para position, that is, on either side of the aromatic ring. Estragol is an isomer of anethole, another aromatic compound, meaning that it shares the same molecular formula but differs in the position of the atoms, resulting in distinct properties and uses.
At room temperature, estragole is a viscous liquid, generally colorless to yellowish, with a characteristic anise-like odor. This olfactory property makes it a sought-after ingredient in several applications, particularly in perfumery and as a food flavoring. However, estragole is also known for its potentially toxic properties, which raises safety and regulatory concerns.
Difference with anethole
Although estragole and anethole are isomers and share a similar odor, their distinct structures lead them to interact differently with the body and have varying effects. The main difference lies in the position of the double bond in the allyl chain of anethole, a characteristic that, while minute, can significantly alter the metabolic pathways and physiological effects of each compound. While anethole is used in perfumery and the food industry without raising the same concerns, estragole, on the other hand, is being studied for its genotoxic and carcinogenic potential, hence the restrictions surrounding its use.
Natural occurrence of estragole: Where is it found?
Main sources in essential oils
Estragole is a major constituent of several essential oils. It is particularly abundant in tarragon essential oil (Artemisia dracunculus), where it represents between 60 and 75% of the total composition. Tarragon is therefore the main source of estragole, which is also how it got its name.
Other plants and essential oils also contain estragole, although in varying proportions. For example, it is present in basil essential oil (Ocimum basilicum) with a concentration ranging from 23 to 88%, as well as in the essential oils of fennel (Foeniculum vulgare), anise (Pimpinella anisum) and star anise (Illicium verum).
Apart from these plants, estragole is also detectable in small quantities in other sources such as turpentine (derived from pine), allspice, nutmeg and even tea leaves.
This varied distribution makes it a relatively widespread aromatic compound in plant-based products.
Estragole concentrations according to plants
Estragole levels can vary considerably depending on the plant and essential oil. In tarragon essential oil, high concentrations of estragole make it a key element of its aromatic profile, while in basil, the concentration is more variable.
Indeed, basil varieties such as tropical basil tend to contain more estragole than common basil. This variability sometimes complicates the control of estragole levels in derived products and poses challenges for the regulation and standardization of essential oils used in commercial settings.
In some cases, essential oil producers may adjust their extraction methods to maximize or minimize the concentration of estragole depending on the desired application, particularly for regulatory safety or taste reasons.
List of plants containing estragole
Here are the main plants and sources containing estragole, along with an overview of their concentrations:
- Tarragon (Artemisia dracunculus) : 60-75 %
- Basil (Ocimum basilicum) : 23-88%, depending on the variety
- Anise (Pimpinella anisum) : approximately 2%
- Fennel (Foeniculum vulgare) : low concentration, present but variable
- Star anise (Illicium verum) : low concentration, present but variable
- Nutmeg (Myristica fragrans) : traces
- Allspice (Pimenta dioica) : traces
- Lemongrass (Cymbopogon) : traces
These concentration levels influence not only the aroma and flavor of essential oils, but also their toxicity potential depending on the use. Plants with high concentrations, such as tarragon and basil, are primarily used for aromatic and culinary applications, but in controlled proportions to limit risks.
In summary, estragole is a natural aromatic compound found in several plants. Its distribution, influenced by the species and extraction method, makes it a valuable ingredient, but also one that is regulated due to its potential health risks.
What is estragole used for? Applications and uses
Use in perfumery
Estragole is highly prized in the perfume industry for its unique, anise-like fragrance. It is used as a base ingredient in fragrance creation, particularly for herbaceous and spicy notes, which are often sought after in perfumes and eau de toilettes with green or oriental undertones. In perfumery, estragole plays a crucial role in adding depth and warmth to olfactory compositions, providing an effect that is both sweet and spicy.
The demand for estragole in fragrance applications is partly due to its volatility, which allows for a gradual and persistent diffusion of its scent. However, regulations surrounding this compound require limited concentrations to avoid any risk to consumers, due to its toxicological potential.
Food and beverage flavoring
Estragole is also used as a natural flavoring in food and beverages, thanks to its ability to enhance flavors. Its taste, similar to anise and fennel, makes it popular in certain liqueurs, such as absinthe and pastis, where it contributes to the distinctive aniseed aroma of these drinks. It is also found, in small quantities, in some candies, baked goods, and desserts.
However, due to its risk profile, the European Union strictly limits its use in food. According to EU Regulation 1334/2008, estragole cannot be added as a pure additive to foodstuffs, but it is permitted when it occurs naturally in extracts or plant-based ingredients with flavoring properties, within specific limits. This regulation ensures control over the doses of estragole ingested by consumers, reducing the risks associated with prolonged exposure.
Other applications: potential insecticidal, antiviral and antibacterial
In addition to its aromatic applications, estragole possesses biological properties that are of interest in a variety of fields. Studies show that certain essential oils containing estragole exhibit insecticidal activity. These properties can be exploited in the formulation of natural insect control products, particularly in organic farming or for domestic use.
Estragole and essential oils containing it, such as basil or tarragon, also exhibit antiviral and antibacterial effects, although these uses are still under investigation. Research is focusing on their potential to inhibit the growth of certain pathogens, which could make them a useful component in natural health and wellness product formulations.
In summary, although estragole is a valued aromatic compound in various sectors, its use is governed by strict regulations aimed at minimizing health risks. Its insecticidal, antiviral, and antibacterial properties open up potential applications in new fields, although further research is needed to confirm its efficacy and safety in these applications.
Are you looking for an analysis?
Regulations and restrictions on estragole
European regulations
In Europe, estragole is strictly regulated as a flavoring ingredient. According to EU Regulation 1334/2008, estragole is classified as a "substance which may not be added as such to foodstuffs." This means that pure estragole cannot be used as an additive in food products. However, it is permitted in limited quantities when it occurs naturally in flavorings or plant extracts, such as tarragon essential oil, to provide flavor without compromising consumer safety. The permitted limits vary depending on the food, generally from 10 to 50 mg/kg, to prevent excessive ingestion.
European regulations are based on toxicological studies, which indicate that estragole can pose risks to human health, particularly at high doses or in sensitive individuals. Health authorities in Europe rely on ongoing monitoring of new studies and adjust permissible exposure levels accordingly to protect consumers.
Requirements in the United States
In the United States, the regulatory approach to estragole is slightly different. The U.S. Department of Agriculture and the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) classify estragole as a "generally recognized as safe" (GRAS) component when it occurs naturally in food. This classification means that, while estragole can be consumed in small amounts, it should not be added as an isolated additive to food products.
US authorities permit the use of essential oils containing estragole, such as basil oil, in food manufacturing, provided that the minimum doses required for flavoring purposes are respected. However, this regulation is subject to periodic review and may change as research on the effects of estragole progresses.
Precautions for vulnerable groups
Additional precautions are recommended for certain population groups considered more sensitive to the potential effects of estragole. Children, pregnant women, and breastfeeding women are particularly targeted, as studies indicate that the genotoxic and carcinogenic effects of estragole may be amplified in these groups due to their specific physiology.
To minimize risks, current recommendations encourage individuals in these groups to avoid herbal products containing high amounts of estragole, such as certain herbal teas, dietary supplements, and essential oils. Estragole doses should also be limited in the presence of chronic illnesses or repeated exposure, which could increase the risk of toxicity.
In conclusion, regulations on estragole are designed to balance the benefits of this aromatic compound with potential health risks. Concentration limits set by health authorities in Europe and the United States ensure that exposure remains within acceptable levels, although specific restrictions are in place to protect the most vulnerable populations.
Laboratory analysis of estragole: techniques and requirements
Objectives of estragole analysis
Estragole analysis is crucial in several industrial sectors, including food, cosmetics, and herbal medicine. It ensures that products meet safety standards, especially when estragole occurs naturally in plant extracts or essential oils used in formulations. Beyond regulatory compliance, analysis helps guarantee product quality and minimize risks to consumers. Testing can also detect any potential cross-contamination or unauthorized presence of estragole in products that should not contain it.
Analytical methods and assay techniques
A frequently used method for estragole analysis is screening by HS-GC-MS (Headspace-Gas Chromatography-Mass Spectrometry), which is particularly effective for volatile compounds such as estragole. This method allows for the precise separation, identification, and quantification of the components of a gas-phase sample, thus facilitating the detection of estragole in complex matrices such as essential oils or plant extracts.
Test details:
- Sample collection and packaging : To guarantee sample integrity, it is necessary to collect samples in sealed and chemically inert containers, such as airtight glass bottles. This packaging limits the risk of contamination or loss of volatile compounds, ensuring greater reliability of the results.
- Limit of quantification (LOQ) : The sensitivity of the HS-GC-MS method allows estragole to be quantified at very low levels, generally between 0.1 and 10 mg/L depending on the specific needs of the analysis and the nature of the matrix.
- Internal method : The technique relies on standardized internal methods that ensure optimal reproducibility and accuracy. These methods follow strict protocols, often conforming to ISO 17025 standards, to provide reliable results to client industries.
Example of laboratory analysis
In the laboratory, a practical example of estragole quantification involves analyzing samples of organic powdered dill, often performed to verify compliance with food regulations. For this example, GC-FID (Gas Chromatography with Flame Ionization Detection) is used in conjunction with HS-GC-MS to enhance detection sensitivity in plant matrices. The limit of quantification (LOQ) is set at approximately 10 ppm, enabling the detection of estragole even at low concentrations, crucial in products intended for human consumption.
YesWeLab Laboratories : YesWeLab laboratories offer comprehensive solutions for estragole analysis in collaboration with a vast network of specialized partner laboratories. This service allows companies to guarantee the quality and safety of their products while complying with current regulatory standards. Through a digital platform, YesWeLab centralizes and simplifies the process, from ordering analyses to tracking samples, ensuring time savings and complete traceability for industrial clients.
In conclusion, laboratory analysis of estragole is essential for monitoring levels of this compound in products, ensuring regulatory compliance, and guaranteeing consumer safety. HS-GC-MS and GC-FID methods are among the most effective for obtaining accurate results, helping industries meet stringent quality and safety requirements.
Conclusion
Estragole is a natural compound with powerful aromatic properties, widely found in plants such as tarragon, basil, and fennel. Its unique chemical structure, combined with its volatility, makes it valuable in the perfume, food flavoring, and even some cosmetic . However, its genotoxic and carcinogenic potential has led European and American authorities to impose strict usage restrictions aimed at protecting consumers from excessive exposure.
Toxicological studies have shown that, while minimal doses are safe, prolonged exposure or high concentrations can pose health risks. Current regulations allow limited use of estragole only when it occurs naturally in flavorings or plant extracts, thus ensuring a controlled level of safety.
In short, estragole, while valued for its aromatic properties, requires controlled and monitored use. The combined efforts of industry, regulators, and laboratories are crucial to ensuring that this natural compound is used safely and in accordance with established standards.
